What are some objections to the importance of AI alignment?

From Stampy's Wiki

Alternate Phrasings

Canonical Answer

Søren Elverlin has compiled a list of counter-arguments and suggests dividing them into two kinds: weak and strong.

Weak counter-arguments point to problems with the "standard" arguments (as given in, e.g., Bostrom’s Superintelligence), especially shaky models and assumptions that are too strong. These arguments are often of a substantial quality and are often presented by people who themselves worry about AI safety. Elverin calls these objections “weak” because they do not attempt to imply that the probability of a bad outcome is close to zero: “For example, even if you accept Paul Christiano's arguments against “fast takeoff”, they only drive the probability of this down to about 20%. Weak counter-arguments are interesting, but the decision to personally focus on AI safety doesn't strongly depend on the probability – anything above 5% is clearly a big enough deal that it doesn't make sense to work on other things.”

Strong arguments argue that the probability of existential catastrophe due to misaligned AI is tiny, usually by some combination of claiming that AGI is impossible or very far away. For example, Michael Littman has suggested that as (he believes) we’re so far from AGI, there will be a long period of human history wherein we’ll have ample time to grow up alongside powerful AIs and figure out how to align them.

Elverlin opines that “There are few arguments that are both high-quality and strong enough to qualify as an ‘objection to the importance of alignment’.” He suggests Rohin Shah's arguments for “alignment by default” as one of the better candidates.

MIRI's April fools "Death With Dignity" strategy might be seen as an argument against the importance of working on alignment, but only in the sense that we might have almost no hope of solving it. In the same category are the “something else will kill us first, so there’s no point worrying about AI alignment” arguments.

Stamps: None
Show your endorsement of this answer by giving it a stamp of approval!

Tags: objections (create tag) (edit tags)

Canonical Question Info
(edits welcome)
Asked by: Nico Hill2
OriginWhere was this question originally asked
Wiki
Date: 2022/03/28

Related questions


Discussion